| Time: May into July, 1794 |
| Place: England and France. |
ACT I |
|---|
| "Madame Guillotine" | Ensemble |
| "Believe" | Percy, Marguerite and Ensemble |
| "Vivez!" | Marguerite, Lady Digby, Lady Llewellyn, Percy and Ensemble |
| "Prayer" | Percy |
| "Into The Fire" | Percy and The League |
| "Falcon in the Dive" | Chauvelin |
| "When I Look At You" | Marguerite |
| "The Scarlet Pimpernel" | Percy, Marguerite, Marie, Armand, Lady Digby, Lady Llewellyn and Servants |
| "Where's the Girl?" | Chauvelin |
| "When I Look at You" (Reprise) | Percy |
| "The Creation of Man" | Percy, Prince of Wales and The League |
| Marguerite's Dilemma | Chauvelin and Marguerite |
| "The Riddle" | Chauvelin, Marguerite, Percy and Ensemble |
ACT II |
|---|
| "They Seek Him Here" | Percy, Prince of Wales, Lady Digby, Lady Llewellyn and Ensemble |
| "Only Love" | Marguerite |
| "She Was There" | Percy |
| "Storybook" | Leontine and French Chorus |
| "Where's the Girl?" (Reprise) | Chauvelin |
| "Lullaby" | Helene and Chloe |
| "You Are My Home" | Marguerite, Armand and French Prisoners |
| The Duel | Percy and Chauvelin |
| "Believe" (Reprise) | Percy, Marguerite and Company |
| "Into the Fire" (Reprise) | Company |